How State Budgets Are Built and Passed

how do state budgets work

Wondering how do state budgets work when a deadline makes the news? A governor proposes, the legislature amends and passes, and the governor signs or vetoes. Details differ by state.

This guide is part of the wider topic of how state government works, and it follows a budget from first request to final signature.

Item Value
States with an annual budget and annual sessions 30 states
States with annual sessions and a biennial budget 16 states
States with a biennial budget and biennial sessions 4 states
States with one omnibus appropriations bill 15 states
States with some tax or expenditure limitation 30 states
New fiscal year in the typical NCSL timeline July 1

These figures come from the National Conference of State Legislatures presentation on budgeting in the states. States change their rules, so check the source before you rely on them.

The budget calendar, step by step

A state budget follows a repeating rhythm, but no two states budget the same way, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL). Its typical timeline runs like this:

  1. September to October: agencies submit budget requests.
  2. January: the governor submits a budget to the legislature.
  3. February to May: the legislature holds budget hearings.
  4. March to June: the legislature adopts the budget.
  5. July 1: the new fiscal year begins.

Treat this as a typical pattern, not a rule. North Carolina’s fiscal year, for example, begins July 1 and ends June 30 of the following calendar year, according to the state’s Office of State Budget and Management. New York’s budget must be enacted by April 1, the start of its fiscal year, according to the state’s citizen’s guide.

how do state budgets work Budget calculations
A person holds a pink calculator above papers and orange folders.

Who does what: agencies, governor and legislature

Three groups shape every state budget, and each has a distinct job:

  • Agencies ask for money. In North Carolina, state agencies submit their budget needs to the budget office, which reviews them with the Governor’s Office (OSBM budget basics).
  • The governor assembles a proposal. New York uses an Executive Budget model, in which the Governor is responsible for developing and preparing a comprehensive and balanced budget proposal (New York citizen’s guide).
  • The legislature appropriates funds. In practice, NCSL notes, the governor’s proposed budget drives the discussion (NCSL).

North Carolina starts with a consensus revenue forecast, which projects what state revenues will be for the fiscal years the budget covers, according to the OSBM budget basics page. The state’s budget office and the General Assembly’s Fiscal Research Division develop that forecast. The state must also keep a balanced budget, which means revenues must cover all spending.

Inside the legislature, most states have an appropriations or budget committee in both chambers, and some also have a joint budget or fiscal committee, per NCSL. Bills often carry a fiscal note, prepared by the executive or legislative branch, that shows the direct impact on the state budget for 1-2 fiscal years.

How does a budget actually get passed?

New York’s process is a useful worked example because its constitution spells out each step. The Governor must submit the budget along with the appropriation bills needed to carry it out, as the New York citizen’s guide explains. An appropriation is the authorization, through law, to allocate funds.

After submission, the Governor can send technical corrections and revisions within 30 days. A 2007 reform law asks the Executive, to the extent practicable, to submit any necessary amendments within 21 days. Public hearings are then scheduled by the Senate Finance and Assembly Ways and Means Committees, and conference committees help the two houses agree.

The final steps hinge on the line item veto. Appropriations proposed by the Governor become law immediately when the Legislature passes them, except for those for the Legislature and the Judiciary. Items the Legislature adds must go to the Governor for approval or veto, and a two-thirds vote of each house can override a veto, per the same guide.

North Carolina shows a different path. The General Assembly passes a budget in an appropriations act, and the governor signs or vetoes it. If the legislature overrides a veto, the act becomes law without the governor’s signature, and afterward the budget office certifies each agency’s budget, according to OSBM.

The number of bills also varies. NCSL reports that 15 states have one omnibus appropriations bill and 35 have multiple appropriation bills, and many of those have two: an operations bill and a capital budget bill (NCSL).

How state budgets differ: annual or biennial

Some states budget every year and others use a longer cycle. NCSL sorts them by how often they budget and how often they meet:

  • 30 states have an annual budget and annual sessions.
  • 16 states have annual sessions and a biennial budget.
  • 4 states have a biennial budget and biennial sessions.

North Carolina is an example of a biennial budget: it covers two fiscal years, and adjustments can be made to the budget for the second year, according to OSBM. That means a news story about a “mid-cycle” budget is often about those second-year changes.

States also differ in how they decide dollar amounts. NCSL describes these approaches:

  • Incremental: the most common approach, which uses the previous year as a baseline.
  • Performance-based: sets measurable goals and focuses on outcomes.
  • Zero-based: reviews budgets from $0, though no states use it in its true form, only variations.

What happens when a budget is late?

A late budget does not always mean a shutdown. NCSL lists several outcomes when a budget is not enacted by the start of the fiscal year: continuing resolutions or temporary spending plans, automatic continuation, courts ruling that some funding continues, and a partial or full government shutdown (NCSL).

North Carolina’s budget office says that if a veto is not overridden, the state operates under a continuing resolution until a new appropriations act is passed and signed into law (OSBM). When a funding fight reaches a courtroom, how to find state court records explains where the paperwork may be found.

Once a budget is law, governors tend to hold more control than legislatures, partly because most legislatures are part-time. In a majority of states the governor can withhold funds to agencies, and governors have the authority to transfer funds, per NCSL. For another view of state officials and their powers, see what does a state attorney general do.

What limits how much a state can spend?

Balanced-budget rules are the first limit. North Carolina, for instance, must keep revenues in line with all spending, as OSBM describes.

Other limits are written into law. Thirty states have some sort of tax or expenditure limitation, according to NCSL, and its examples include Colorado’s TABOR, which it calls the most stringent, and Oregon’s “Kicker” law.

Earmarking also narrows choices. On average, states earmark about 25 percent of revenue. The upside is a dedicated funding source for programs; the downside is less flexibility during an economic downturn, per the same NCSL presentation.

When you read budget coverage, check three things:

  • Whether the state budgets annually or biennially.
  • Whether the governor or the legislature is holding up the bill.
  • What happens by law if the deadline passes.

Frequently asked questions

What is an appropriation?

Show answer

It is the authorization, through law, to allocate funds. New York’s constitution says no money may be paid out of the state treasury except in pursuance of an appropriation by law, as the state’s citizen’s guide notes.

What is a fiscal year?

Show answer

It is the budget year, and its dates are set by each state. In North Carolina, the fiscal year begins July 1 and ends June 30 of the following calendar year, according to OSBM.

Can a governor veto part of a budget?

Show answer

In New York, yes: the Constitution grants the Governor “line item veto” power, which permits vetoing items selectively while approving the rest of the bill. A two-thirds vote of each house can override, per the New York citizen’s guide. Other states have their own rules.

Where can you read a state’s budget?

Show answer

Many state budget offices publish documents online. North Carolina’s budget office points to an Open Budget site where you can explore state budgets and expenditures, as its budget basics page shows.