A shopper recently decided to compare prices between Walmart and Aldi using the same grocery list. The idea was simple—see which store gives better value for a typical family shopping trip.
After visiting both stores with her family’s list in hand, the result was clear: Aldi came out cheaper. But even with the savings, the shopper isn’t fully convinced she’ll be switching stores anytime soon.
She started her shopping trip at Walmart, which is a store she visits regularly. It’s familiar, convenient, and usually well-stocked. For this trip, she focused only on groceries, skipping things like toiletries or cleaning supplies.
At Walmart, she bought 17 items from her family’s list and paid $88.73 in total. A few things weren’t available in the exact brand or size she wanted, but she was able to make it work.
Next, she headed to Aldi. Known for its low prices, Aldi has become popular among shoppers looking to save. Unlike Walmart, Aldi doesn’t carry many big-name brands and focuses mostly on store-brand items.
When she compared her shopping list, she found almost everything she needed at Aldi—except for one or two things. The total bill at Aldi came to $76.48 for 16 similar items. That’s a savings of $12.25 compared to Walmart.
But even though the prices were lower at Aldi, the experience wasn’t perfect. The shopper noticed a few key differences between the two stores that made her hesitate about returning to Aldi.
One major issue was product availability. While Aldi had most of the grocery items she needed, it didn’t offer the same variety as Walmart.
For example, if you’re looking for a specific brand or a wider choice of flavors and types, Walmart has more options. Aldi sticks to its private-label brands, which means fewer choices.
Another thing she noticed was the store layout and size. Aldi stores are smaller and feel more limited in space. Some sections, like produce and bakery, are more compact than Walmart’s. That can make shopping feel a bit rushed or cramped, especially if it’s crowded.
There were also small differences in product quality. She felt that some items at Aldi—like the bananas and bread—weren’t as fresh or appealing as what she got at Walmart. While everything was still safe and edible, these minor things added up in her mind.
Aldi’s checkout process is different, too. Shoppers have to bag their groceries after paying, and there are usually fewer employees at each location.
That can mean longer lines and a more hands-on experience overall. She also had to bring her shopping bags and insert a coin to use a cart—something Walmart doesn’t require.
Despite all this, the price difference was real. Saving over $12 on a small grocery run is nothing to ignore, especially during times when food costs are rising.
For families on a tight budget, Aldi could offer serious relief. But for this shopper, it wasn’t just about money—it was about convenience, selection, and comfort too.
In the end, while Aldi did prove to be the more budget-friendly option, the shopper said she’s not ready to make a full switch. She might go back occasionally to stock up on a few essentials, but she still prefers the overall experience and options that Walmart provides.
The comparison reminded her that saving money sometimes comes with trade-offs, and what works best depends on each shopper’s priorities.